Stay Ahead, Stay ONMINE

How to build a better AI benchmark

It’s not easy being one of Silicon Valley’s favorite benchmarks.  SWE-Bench (pronounced “swee bench”) launched in November 2024 to evaluate an AI model’s coding skill, using more than 2,000 real-world programming problems pulled from the public GitHub repositories of 12 different Python-based projects.  In the months since then, it’s quickly become one of the most popular tests in AI. A SWE-Bench score has become a mainstay of major model releases from OpenAI, Anthropic, and Google—and outside of foundation models, the fine-tuners at AI firms are in constant competition to see who can rise above the pack. The top of the leaderboard is a pileup between three different fine tunings of Anthropic’s Claude Sonnet model and Amazon’s Q developer agent. Auto Code Rover—one of the Claude modifications—nabbed the number two spot in November, and was acquired just three months later. Despite all the fervor, this isn’t exactly a truthful assessment of which model is “better.” As the benchmark has gained prominence, “you start to see that people really want that top spot,” says John Yang, a researcher on the team that developed SWE-Bench at Princeton University. As a result, entrants have begun to game the system—which is pushing many others to wonder whether there’s a better way to actually measure AI achievement. Developers of these coding agents aren’t necessarily doing anything as straightforward cheating, but they’re crafting approaches that are too neatly tailored to the specifics of the benchmark. The initial SWE-Bench test set was limited to programs written in Python, which meant developers could gain an advantage by training their models exclusively on Python code. Soon, Yang noticed that high-scoring models would fail completely when tested on different programming languages—revealing an approach to the test that he describes as “gilded.” “It looks nice and shiny at first glance, but then you try to run it on a different language and the whole thing just kind of falls apart,” Yang says. “At that point, you’re not designing a software engineering agent. You’re designing to make a SWE-Bench agent, which is much less interesting.” The SWE-Bench issue is a symptom of a more sweeping—and complicated—problem in AI evaluation, and one that’s increasingly sparking heated debate: The benchmarks the industry uses to guide development are drifting further and further away from evaluating actual capabilities, calling their basic value into question. Making the situation worse, several benchmarks, most notably FrontierMath and Chatbot Arena, have recently come under heat for an alleged lack of transparency. Nevertheless, benchmarks still play a central role in model development, even if few experts are willing to take their results at face value. OpenAI cofounder Andrej Karpathy recently described the situation as “an evaluation crisis”: the industry has fewer trusted methods for measuring capabilities and no clear path to better ones.  “Historically, benchmarks were the way we evaluated AI systems,” says Vanessa Parli, director of research at Stanford University’s Institute for Human-Centered AI. “Is that the way we want to evaluate systems going forward? And if it’s not, what is the way?” A growing group of academics and AI researchers are making the case that the answer is to go smaller, trading sweeping ambition for an approach inspired by the social sciences. Specifically, they want to focus more on testing validity, which for quantitative social scientists refers to how well a given questionnaire measures what it’s claiming to measure—and, more fundamentally, whether what it is measuring has a coherent definition. That could cause trouble for benchmarks assessing hazily defined concepts like “reasoning” or “scientific knowledge”—and for developers aiming to reach the much-hyped goal of artificial general intelligence—but it would put the industry on firmer ground as it looks to prove the worth of individual models. “Taking validity seriously means asking folks in academia, industry, or wherever to show that their system does what they say it does,” says Abigail Jacobs, a University of Michigan professor who is a central figure in the new push for validity. “I think it points to a weakness in the AI world if they want to back off from showing that they can support their claim.” The limits of traditional testing If AI companies have been slow to respond to the growing failure of benchmarks, it’s partially because the test-scoring approach has been so effective for so long.  One of the biggest early successes of contemporary AI was the ImageNet challenge, a kind of antecedent to contemporary benchmarks. Released in 2010 as an open challenge to researchers, the database held more than 3 million images for AI systems to categorize into 1,000 different classes. Crucially, the test was completely agnostic to methods, and any successful algorithm quickly gained credibility regardless of how it worked. When an algorithm called AlexNet broke through in 2012, with a then unconventional form of GPU training, it became one of the foundational results of modern AI. Few would have guessed in advance that AlexNet’s convolutional neural nets would be the secret to unlocking image recognition—but after it scored well, no one dared dispute it. (One of AlexNet’s developers, Ilya Sutskever, would go on to cofound OpenAI.) A large part of what made this challenge so effective was that there was little practical difference between ImageNet’s object classification challenge and the actual process of asking a computer to recognize an image. Even if there were disputes about methods, no one doubted that the highest-scoring model would have an advantage when deployed in an actual image recognition system. But in the 12 years since, AI researchers have applied that same method-agnostic approach to increasingly general tasks. SWE-Bench is commonly used as a proxy for broader coding ability, while other exam-style benchmarks often stand in for reasoning ability. That broad scope makes it difficult to be rigorous about what a specific benchmark measures—which, in turn, makes it hard to use the findings responsibly.  Where things break down Anka Reuel, a PhD student who has been focusing on the benchmark problem as part of her research at Stanford, has become convinced the evaluation problem is the result of this push toward generality. “We’ve moved from task-specific models to general-purpose models,” Reuel says. “It’s not about a single task anymore but a whole bunch of tasks, so evaluation becomes harder.” Like the University of Michigan’s Jacobs, Reuel thinks “the main issue with benchmarks is validity, even more than the practical implementation,” noting: “That’s where a lot of things break down.” For a task as complicated as coding, for instance, it’s nearly impossible to incorporate every possible scenario into your problem set. As a result, it’s hard to gauge whether a model is scoring better because it’s more skilled at coding or because it has more effectively manipulated the problem set. And with so much pressure on developers to achieve record scores, shortcuts are hard to resist. For developers, the hope is that success on lots of specific benchmarks will add up to a generally capable model. But the techniques of agentic AI mean a single AI system can encompass a complex array of different models, making it hard to evaluate whether improvement on a specific task will lead to generalization. “There’s just many more knobs you can turn,” says Sayash Kapoor, a computer scientist at Princeton and a prominent critic of sloppy practices in the AI industry. “When it comes to agents, they have sort of given up on the best practices for evaluation.” In a paper from last July, Kapoor called out specific issues in how AI models were approaching the WebArena benchmark, designed by Carnegie Mellon University researchers in 2024 as a test of an AI agent’s ability to traverse the web. The benchmark consists of more than 800 tasks to be performed on a set of cloned websites mimicking Reddit, Wikipedia, and others. Kapoor and his team identified an apparent hack in the winning model, called STeP. STeP included specific instructions about how Reddit structures URLs, allowing STeP models to jump directly to a given user’s profile page (a frequent element of WebArena tasks). This shortcut wasn’t exactly cheating, but Kapoor sees it as “a serious misrepresentation of how well the agent would work had it seen the tasks in WebArena for the first time.” Because the technique was successful, though, a similar policy has since been adopted by OpenAI’s web agent Operator. (“Our evaluation setting is designed to assess how well an agent can solve tasks given some instruction about website structures and task execution,” an OpenAI representative said when reached for comment. “This approach is consistent with how others have used and reported results with WebArena.” STeP did not respond to a request for comment.) Further highlighting the problem with AI benchmarks, late last month Kapoor and a team of researchers wrote a paper that revealed significant problems in Chatbot Arena, the popular crowdsourced evaluation system. According to the paper, the leaderboard was being manipulated; many top foundation models were conducting undisclosed private testing and releasing their scores selectively. Today, even ImageNet itself, the mother of all benchmarks, has started to fall victim to validity problems. A 2023 study from researchers at the University of Washington and Google Research found that when ImageNet-winning algorithms were pitted against six real-world data sets, the architecture improvement “resulted in little to no progress,” suggesting that the external validity of the test had reached its limit. Going smaller For those who believe the main problem is validity, the best fix is reconnecting benchmarks to specific tasks. As Reuel puts it, AI developers “have to resort to these high-level benchmarks that are almost meaningless for downstream consumers, because the benchmark developers can’t anticipate the downstream task anymore.” So what if there was a way to help the downstream consumers identify this gap? In November 2024, Reuel launched a public ranking project called BetterBench, which rates benchmarks on dozens of different criteria, such as whether the code has been publicly documented. But validity is a central theme, with particular criteria challenging designers to spell out what capability their benchmark is testing and how it relates to the tasks that make up the benchmark. “You need to have a structural breakdown of the capabilities,” Reuel says. “What are the actual skills you care about, and how do you operationalize them into something we can measure?” The results are surprising. One of the highest-scoring benchmarks is also the oldest: the Arcade Learning Environment (ALE), established in 2013 as a way to test models’ ability to learn how to play a library of Atari 2600 games. One of the lowest-scoring is the Massive Multitask Language Understanding (MMLU) benchmark, a widely used test for general language skills; by the standards of BetterBench, the connection between the questions and the underlying skill was too poorly defined. BetterBench hasn’t meant much for the reputations of specific benchmarks, at least not yet; MMLU is still widely used, and ALE is still marginal. But the project has succeeded in pushing validity into the broader conversation about how to fix benchmarks. In April, Reuel quietly joined a new research group hosted by Hugging Face, the University of Edinburgh, and EleutherAI, where she’ll develop her ideas on validity and AI model evaluation with other figures in the field. (An official announcement is expected later this month.)  Irene Solaiman, Hugging Face’s head of global policy, says the group will focus on building valid benchmarks that go beyond measuring straightforward capabilities. “There’s just so much hunger for a good benchmark off the shelf that already works,” Solaiman says. “A lot of evaluations are trying to do too much.” Increasingly, the rest of the industry seems to agree. In a paper in March, researchers from Google, Microsoft, Anthropic, and others laid out a new framework for improving evaluations—with validity as the first step.  “AI evaluation science must,” the researchers argue, “move beyond coarse grained claims of ‘general intelligence’ towards more task-specific and real-world relevant measures of progress.”  Measuring the “squishy” things To help make this shift, some researchers are looking to the tools of social science. A February position paper argued that “evaluating GenAI systems is a social science measurement challenge,” specifically unpacking how the validity systems used in social measurements can be applied to AI benchmarking.  The authors, largely employed by Microsoft’s research branch but joined by academics from Stanford and the University of Michigan, point to the standards that social scientists use to measure contested concepts like ideology, democracy, and media bias. Applied to AI benchmarks, those same procedures could offer a way to measure concepts like “reasoning” and “math proficiency” without slipping into hazy generalizations. In the social science literature, it’s particularly important that metrics begin with a rigorous definition of the concept measured by the test. For instance, if the test is to measure how democratic a society is, it first needs to establish a definition for a “democratic society” and then establish questions that are relevant to that definition.  To apply this to a benchmark like SWE-Bench, designers would need to set aside the classic machine learning approach, which is to collect programming problems from GitHub and create a scheme to validate answers as true or false. Instead, they’d first need to define what the benchmark aims to measure (“ability to resolve flagged issues in software,” for instance), break that into subskills (different types of problems or types of program that the AI model can successfully process), and then finally assemble questions that accurately cover the different subskills. It’s a profound change from how AI researchers typically approach benchmarking—but for researchers like Jacobs, a coauthor on the February paper, that’s the whole point. “There’s a mismatch between what’s happening in the tech industry and these tools from social science,” she says. “We have decades and decades of thinking about how we want to measure these squishy things about humans.” Even though the idea has made a real impact in the research world, it’s been slow to influence the way AI companies are actually using benchmarks.  The last two months have seen new model releases from OpenAI, Anthropic, Google, and Meta, and all of them lean heavily on multiple-choice knowledge benchmarks like MMLU—the exact approach that validity researchers are trying to move past. After all, model releases are, for the most part, still about showing increases in general intelligence, and broad benchmarks continue to be used to back up those claims.  For some observers, that’s good enough. Benchmarks, Wharton professor Ethan Mollick says, are “bad measures of things, but also they’re what we’ve got.” He adds: “At the same time, the models are getting better. A lot of sins are forgiven by fast progress.” For now, the industry’s long-standing focus on artificial general intelligence seems to be crowding out a more focused validity-based approach. As long as AI models can keep growing in general intelligence, then specific applications don’t seem as compelling—even if that leaves practitioners relying on tools they no longer fully trust.  “This is the tightrope we’re walking,” says Hugging Face’s Solaiman. “It’s too easy to throw the system out, but evaluations are really helpful in understanding our models, even with these limitations.” Russell Brandom is a freelance writer covering artificial intelligence. He lives in Brooklyn with his wife and two cats. This story was supported by a grant from the Tarbell Center for AI Journalism.

It’s not easy being one of Silicon Valley’s favorite benchmarks. 

SWE-Bench (pronounced “swee bench”) launched in November 2024 to evaluate an AI model’s coding skill, using more than 2,000 real-world programming problems pulled from the public GitHub repositories of 12 different Python-based projects. 

In the months since then, it’s quickly become one of the most popular tests in AI. A SWE-Bench score has become a mainstay of major model releases from OpenAI, Anthropic, and Google—and outside of foundation models, the fine-tuners at AI firms are in constant competition to see who can rise above the pack. The top of the leaderboard is a pileup between three different fine tunings of Anthropic’s Claude Sonnet model and Amazon’s Q developer agent. Auto Code Rover—one of the Claude modifications—nabbed the number two spot in November, and was acquired just three months later.

Despite all the fervor, this isn’t exactly a truthful assessment of which model is “better.” As the benchmark has gained prominence, “you start to see that people really want that top spot,” says John Yang, a researcher on the team that developed SWE-Bench at Princeton University. As a result, entrants have begun to game the system—which is pushing many others to wonder whether there’s a better way to actually measure AI achievement.

Developers of these coding agents aren’t necessarily doing anything as straightforward cheating, but they’re crafting approaches that are too neatly tailored to the specifics of the benchmark. The initial SWE-Bench test set was limited to programs written in Python, which meant developers could gain an advantage by training their models exclusively on Python code. Soon, Yang noticed that high-scoring models would fail completely when tested on different programming languages—revealing an approach to the test that he describes as “gilded.”

“It looks nice and shiny at first glance, but then you try to run it on a different language and the whole thing just kind of falls apart,” Yang says. “At that point, you’re not designing a software engineering agent. You’re designing to make a SWE-Bench agent, which is much less interesting.”

The SWE-Bench issue is a symptom of a more sweeping—and complicated—problem in AI evaluation, and one that’s increasingly sparking heated debate: The benchmarks the industry uses to guide development are drifting further and further away from evaluating actual capabilities, calling their basic value into question. Making the situation worse, several benchmarks, most notably FrontierMath and Chatbot Arena, have recently come under heat for an alleged lack of transparency. Nevertheless, benchmarks still play a central role in model development, even if few experts are willing to take their results at face value. OpenAI cofounder Andrej Karpathy recently described the situation as “an evaluation crisis”: the industry has fewer trusted methods for measuring capabilities and no clear path to better ones. 

“Historically, benchmarks were the way we evaluated AI systems,” says Vanessa Parli, director of research at Stanford University’s Institute for Human-Centered AI. “Is that the way we want to evaluate systems going forward? And if it’s not, what is the way?”

A growing group of academics and AI researchers are making the case that the answer is to go smaller, trading sweeping ambition for an approach inspired by the social sciences. Specifically, they want to focus more on testing validity, which for quantitative social scientists refers to how well a given questionnaire measures what it’s claiming to measure—and, more fundamentally, whether what it is measuring has a coherent definition. That could cause trouble for benchmarks assessing hazily defined concepts like “reasoning” or “scientific knowledge”—and for developers aiming to reach the much–hyped goal of artificial general intelligence—but it would put the industry on firmer ground as it looks to prove the worth of individual models.

“Taking validity seriously means asking folks in academia, industry, or wherever to show that their system does what they say it does,” says Abigail Jacobs, a University of Michigan professor who is a central figure in the new push for validity. “I think it points to a weakness in the AI world if they want to back off from showing that they can support their claim.”

The limits of traditional testing

If AI companies have been slow to respond to the growing failure of benchmarks, it’s partially because the test-scoring approach has been so effective for so long. 

One of the biggest early successes of contemporary AI was the ImageNet challenge, a kind of antecedent to contemporary benchmarks. Released in 2010 as an open challenge to researchers, the database held more than 3 million images for AI systems to categorize into 1,000 different classes.

Crucially, the test was completely agnostic to methods, and any successful algorithm quickly gained credibility regardless of how it worked. When an algorithm called AlexNet broke through in 2012, with a then unconventional form of GPU training, it became one of the foundational results of modern AI. Few would have guessed in advance that AlexNet’s convolutional neural nets would be the secret to unlocking image recognition—but after it scored well, no one dared dispute it. (One of AlexNet’s developers, Ilya Sutskever, would go on to cofound OpenAI.)

A large part of what made this challenge so effective was that there was little practical difference between ImageNet’s object classification challenge and the actual process of asking a computer to recognize an image. Even if there were disputes about methods, no one doubted that the highest-scoring model would have an advantage when deployed in an actual image recognition system.

But in the 12 years since, AI researchers have applied that same method-agnostic approach to increasingly general tasks. SWE-Bench is commonly used as a proxy for broader coding ability, while other exam-style benchmarks often stand in for reasoning ability. That broad scope makes it difficult to be rigorous about what a specific benchmark measures—which, in turn, makes it hard to use the findings responsibly. 

Where things break down

Anka Reuel, a PhD student who has been focusing on the benchmark problem as part of her research at Stanford, has become convinced the evaluation problem is the result of this push toward generality. “We’ve moved from task-specific models to general-purpose models,” Reuel says. “It’s not about a single task anymore but a whole bunch of tasks, so evaluation becomes harder.”

Like the University of Michigan’s Jacobs, Reuel thinks “the main issue with benchmarks is validity, even more than the practical implementation,” noting: “That’s where a lot of things break down.” For a task as complicated as coding, for instance, it’s nearly impossible to incorporate every possible scenario into your problem set. As a result, it’s hard to gauge whether a model is scoring better because it’s more skilled at coding or because it has more effectively manipulated the problem set. And with so much pressure on developers to achieve record scores, shortcuts are hard to resist.

For developers, the hope is that success on lots of specific benchmarks will add up to a generally capable model. But the techniques of agentic AI mean a single AI system can encompass a complex array of different models, making it hard to evaluate whether improvement on a specific task will lead to generalization. “There’s just many more knobs you can turn,” says Sayash Kapoor, a computer scientist at Princeton and a prominent critic of sloppy practices in the AI industry. “When it comes to agents, they have sort of given up on the best practices for evaluation.”

In a paper from last July, Kapoor called out specific issues in how AI models were approaching the WebArena benchmark, designed by Carnegie Mellon University researchers in 2024 as a test of an AI agent’s ability to traverse the web. The benchmark consists of more than 800 tasks to be performed on a set of cloned websites mimicking Reddit, Wikipedia, and others. Kapoor and his team identified an apparent hack in the winning model, called STeP. STeP included specific instructions about how Reddit structures URLs, allowing STeP models to jump directly to a given user’s profile page (a frequent element of WebArena tasks).

This shortcut wasn’t exactly cheating, but Kapoor sees it as “a serious misrepresentation of how well the agent would work had it seen the tasks in WebArena for the first time.” Because the technique was successful, though, a similar policy has since been adopted by OpenAI’s web agent Operator. (“Our evaluation setting is designed to assess how well an agent can solve tasks given some instruction about website structures and task execution,” an OpenAI representative said when reached for comment. “This approach is consistent with how others have used and reported results with WebArena.” STeP did not respond to a request for comment.)

Further highlighting the problem with AI benchmarks, late last month Kapoor and a team of researchers wrote a paper that revealed significant problems in Chatbot Arena, the popular crowdsourced evaluation system. According to the paper, the leaderboard was being manipulated; many top foundation models were conducting undisclosed private testing and releasing their scores selectively.

Today, even ImageNet itself, the mother of all benchmarks, has started to fall victim to validity problems. A 2023 study from researchers at the University of Washington and Google Research found that when ImageNet-winning algorithms were pitted against six real-world data sets, the architecture improvement “resulted in little to no progress,” suggesting that the external validity of the test had reached its limit.

Going smaller

For those who believe the main problem is validity, the best fix is reconnecting benchmarks to specific tasks. As Reuel puts it, AI developers “have to resort to these high-level benchmarks that are almost meaningless for downstream consumers, because the benchmark developers can’t anticipate the downstream task anymore.” So what if there was a way to help the downstream consumers identify this gap?

In November 2024, Reuel launched a public ranking project called BetterBench, which rates benchmarks on dozens of different criteria, such as whether the code has been publicly documented. But validity is a central theme, with particular criteria challenging designers to spell out what capability their benchmark is testing and how it relates to the tasks that make up the benchmark.

“You need to have a structural breakdown of the capabilities,” Reuel says. “What are the actual skills you care about, and how do you operationalize them into something we can measure?”

The results are surprising. One of the highest-scoring benchmarks is also the oldest: the Arcade Learning Environment (ALE), established in 2013 as a way to test models’ ability to learn how to play a library of Atari 2600 games. One of the lowest-scoring is the Massive Multitask Language Understanding (MMLU) benchmark, a widely used test for general language skills; by the standards of BetterBench, the connection between the questions and the underlying skill was too poorly defined.

BetterBench hasn’t meant much for the reputations of specific benchmarks, at least not yet; MMLU is still widely used, and ALE is still marginal. But the project has succeeded in pushing validity into the broader conversation about how to fix benchmarks. In April, Reuel quietly joined a new research group hosted by Hugging Face, the University of Edinburgh, and EleutherAI, where she’ll develop her ideas on validity and AI model evaluation with other figures in the field. (An official announcement is expected later this month.) 

Irene Solaiman, Hugging Face’s head of global policy, says the group will focus on building valid benchmarks that go beyond measuring straightforward capabilities. “There’s just so much hunger for a good benchmark off the shelf that already works,” Solaiman says. “A lot of evaluations are trying to do too much.”

Increasingly, the rest of the industry seems to agree. In a paper in March, researchers from Google, Microsoft, Anthropic, and others laid out a new framework for improving evaluations—with validity as the first step. 

“AI evaluation science must,” the researchers argue, “move beyond coarse grained claims of ‘general intelligence’ towards more task-specific and real-world relevant measures of progress.” 

Measuring the “squishy” things

To help make this shift, some researchers are looking to the tools of social science. A February position paper argued that “evaluating GenAI systems is a social science measurement challenge,” specifically unpacking how the validity systems used in social measurements can be applied to AI benchmarking. 

The authors, largely employed by Microsoft’s research branch but joined by academics from Stanford and the University of Michigan, point to the standards that social scientists use to measure contested concepts like ideology, democracy, and media bias. Applied to AI benchmarks, those same procedures could offer a way to measure concepts like “reasoning” and “math proficiency” without slipping into hazy generalizations.

In the social science literature, it’s particularly important that metrics begin with a rigorous definition of the concept measured by the test. For instance, if the test is to measure how democratic a society is, it first needs to establish a definition for a “democratic society” and then establish questions that are relevant to that definition. 

To apply this to a benchmark like SWE-Bench, designers would need to set aside the classic machine learning approach, which is to collect programming problems from GitHub and create a scheme to validate answers as true or false. Instead, they’d first need to define what the benchmark aims to measure (“ability to resolve flagged issues in software,” for instance), break that into subskills (different types of problems or types of program that the AI model can successfully process), and then finally assemble questions that accurately cover the different subskills.

It’s a profound change from how AI researchers typically approach benchmarking—but for researchers like Jacobs, a coauthor on the February paper, that’s the whole point. “There’s a mismatch between what’s happening in the tech industry and these tools from social science,” she says. “We have decades and decades of thinking about how we want to measure these squishy things about humans.”

Even though the idea has made a real impact in the research world, it’s been slow to influence the way AI companies are actually using benchmarks. 

The last two months have seen new model releases from OpenAI, Anthropic, Google, and Meta, and all of them lean heavily on multiple-choice knowledge benchmarks like MMLU—the exact approach that validity researchers are trying to move past. After all, model releases are, for the most part, still about showing increases in general intelligence, and broad benchmarks continue to be used to back up those claims. 

For some observers, that’s good enough. Benchmarks, Wharton professor Ethan Mollick says, are “bad measures of things, but also they’re what we’ve got.” He adds: “At the same time, the models are getting better. A lot of sins are forgiven by fast progress.”

For now, the industry’s long-standing focus on artificial general intelligence seems to be crowding out a more focused validity-based approach. As long as AI models can keep growing in general intelligence, then specific applications don’t seem as compelling—even if that leaves practitioners relying on tools they no longer fully trust. 

“This is the tightrope we’re walking,” says Hugging Face’s Solaiman. “It’s too easy to throw the system out, but evaluations are really helpful in understanding our models, even with these limitations.”

Russell Brandom is a freelance writer covering artificial intelligence. He lives in Brooklyn with his wife and two cats.

This story was supported by a grant from the Tarbell Center for AI Journalism.

Shape
Shape
Stay Ahead

Explore More Insights

Stay ahead with more perspectives on cutting-edge power, infrastructure, energy,  bitcoin and AI solutions. Explore these articles to uncover strategies and insights shaping the future of industries.

Shape

What’s next for Nvidia?

That’s if he wants it. One industry watcher told this reporter that several years ago, he asked several Nvidia vice presidents if they wanted the big chair, because Nvidia had no clear successor to Huang and to a man they said no way. “I can’t and don’t want to do

Read More »

People and Vertical AI: The new operating model for energy and utilities

For generations, the energy and utility industry has depended on the judgment of its people.  Across the industry, people are responsible for keeping energy and water running and serving the communities that depend on them. A field crew is there when a community needs power restored. A grid operator carries the responsibility of keeping the network stable and reliable. A customer service representative is often the human connection between a customer and the utility service. An engineer makes decisions that can shape the safety, resilience and reliability of infrastructure for decades.  That expertise remains essential. What has changed is the complexity surrounding it.  Electrification, distributed energy resources, renewable generation, electric vehicles, extreme weather, aging infrastructure, affordability pressures, rising customer expectations and data centers becoming new energy consumers are all connecting decisions that were once managed independently.  The industry has spent decades digitizing those decisions, generating more data along the way. The challenge now is different: how do you make that intelligence work together and make the expertise of the people using it scalable?  This is where AI has to evolve beyond generic intelligence to a Vertical AI approach built around the specific context, complexity and interconnected realities of the energy and utility industry.  The opportunity is not to automate the people who run the industry. It is to give them better context, better intelligence and the ability to extend their judgment across more decisions, more customers and more of the ecosystem than was previously possible.  That is the premise behind People + Vertical AI.  From Human Expertise to Connected Intelligence  People + Vertical AI is not a technology layer placed on top of existing operations. It is an operating model in which Vertical AI works alongside people, connecting information across the enterprise while people provide judgment, accountability and context.  The

Read More »

Energy Secretary Keeps Critical, Coal-Fired Generation Operational Ahead of Winter in the Midwest

WASHINGTON—The U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) issued an emergency order to address critical grid reliability issues in the Midwest. The emergency order directs the Midcontinent Independent System Operator (MISO), in coordination with Consumers Energy Company, to ensure that the coal-fired J.H. Campbell Generating Plant (Campbell Plant) in West Olive, Michigan, is available to operate and meet emergency needs while employing economic dispatch to minimize costs for hardworking American families and businesses. The Campbell Plant was originally slated to shut down on May 31, 2025, 15 years before the end of its scheduled design life.  “President Trump and the Energy Department remain committed to doing everything in our power to stop power outages for American families and businesses,” said U.S. Secretary of Energy Chris Wright. “Ensuring coal plants such as the Campbell Plant are available to operate has prevented blackouts and likely saved lives. Americans deserve access to affordable, reliable, and secure electricity regardless of whether the wind is blowing or the sun is shining.” Thanks to President Trump, coal generating plants across the country are being saved from premature retirement. For example, in 2025, more than 17 gigawatts of coal-fired electricity generation were saved from going offline. During periods of peak electricity demand, many of those plants keep the lights on.  The emergency conditions that led to the issuance of the original order persist. A joint report from the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC), the North American Electric Reliability Corporation (NERC), and NERC’s Regional Entities highlights how events that occurred during the Winter 2026 Arctic Cold Period, including Winter Storm Fern, demonstrated the need for dispatchable generation capacity from facilities like the Campbell Plant.  This order is in effect from November 15, 2026, through February 12, 2027. 

Read More »

Kosmos lets contract to advance Tiberius project offshore Louisiana

Kosmos Energy Gulf of Mexico Operations LLC, a unit of Kosmos Energy, has let a contract to Subsea 7 SA for work on the Tiberius project in the US Gulf of Mexico. The scope of work covers the fabrication, transportation, and installation of a 14-km steel catenary riser and wet-insulated flowline to the Lucius Spar, along with the installation of an umbilical and subsea controls. The Tiberius project lies in Keathley Canyon lease 964 about 400 km south of New Orleans in about 2,283 m of water.  License partners reached a final investment decision on the Phase 1A development this year, which includes completion of an already drilled well. Long-lead items have been secured, and first oil is expected by the end of third-quarter 2028.  Subsea 7, which values the contract at $50-150 million, expects project management and engineering activities to begin in the coming months, with offshore activities expected to begin in 2028. Kosmos is operator of the Tiberius project with a 33.34% interest following a farmout alongside partner Occidental Petroleum to Navitas Petroleum US LLC earlier this year.

Read More »

ExxonMobil takes FID for Longtail development offshore Guyana

The development, in the southeastern portion of the block, will target non-associated gas and condensate-rich reservoirs. Subject to future investment decisions, market demand, and development of supporting infrastructure, gas from the project could be transported to shore by pipeline. The development will use a floating production, storage, and offloading (FPSO) vessel designed to process 1.2 bcfd of gas and produce as much as 250,000 b/d of condensate. The project is expected to include about 45 subsea production and injection wells. “By developing these gas and condensate resources, we’re unlocking new value for Guyana while delivering advantaged energy to meet growing global demand,” said Dan Ammann, president, ExxonMobil Upstream Company. ExxonMobil currently produces about 900,000 b/d of oil from four developments in the Stabroek block. Its fifth project, Uaru, is expected to start up in fourth-quarter 2026, increasing total block production capacity to more than 1 million b/d. Earlier this year, the operator and co-venturers produced the 1 billionth bbl of oil from Guyana’s Stabroek block, less than 7 years after first production began in December 2019 with Liza field. Construction also continues on the Whiptail and Hammerhead developments, the sixth and seventh approved projects on the block. Whiptail is slated to start production in 2027, followed by Hammerhead in 2029. ExxonMobil Guyana Ltd. operates the Stabroek block with a 45% interest. Hess Guyana Exploration Ltd. holds 30%, and CNOOC Petroleum Guyana Ltd. holds 25%.

Read More »

MARAD approves Energy Transfer’s $1-billion Blue Marlin crude oil export port

The US Maritime Administration (MARAD) approved Energy Transfer’s $1-billion Blue Marlin offshore crude oil export project off Louisiana Nov. 5, marking the fourth oil and gas deepwater port approval under President Donald Trump’s second administration. The proposed Blue Marlin port would have capacity to export up to 2 million b/d of crude oil, with loading rates of up to 80,000 bbl/hr, including onto very large crude carriers (VLCCs). Located 99 miles off Cameron Parish, La., the project includes conversion of an existing 36-in. Stingray natural gas pipeline to transport crude oil from Energy Transfer’s Nederland terminal in Texas to the offshore infrastructure. The US Federal Energy Regulatory Commission previously authorized abandonment and sale of Stingray pipeline infrastructure for conversion to crude oil service. Energy Transfer has yet to receive final US Environmental Protection Agency air permits and certain state approvals. The project’s commercial development schedule remains uncertain. MARAD approved Blue Marlin shortly after its Oct. 28 approval of the $8.2-billion ST LNG project offshore Texas, as the agency pursues new procedures to streamline deepwater port licensing. The Trump administration also has approved Delfin LNG, a floating LNG export project offshore Louisiana, and Texas GulfLink, a crude oil export project offshore Texas.

Read More »

IEA sees oil market surplus returning as Gulf exports recover

The global oil market is showing signs of rebalancing as recovering crude exports from the Middle East lift supply, although persistent disruptions to refined product markets, particularly diesel, continue to weigh on consumers, the International Energy Agency (IEA) said. In its Nov. 13 Oil Market Report, IEA said global oil supply increased 2.3 million b/d month-on-month to 105.4 million b/d in October, following a 3 million-b/d increase in September. Output has risen 5.3 million b/d since August as Gulf exports recovered despite continued attacks on energy infrastructure and commercial tankers. The stronger supply outlook has prompted the agency to raise its fourth-quarter 2026 supply estimate by 3.3 million b/d. Global supply is now expected to decline by an average 4.8 million b/d for the full year before rebounding by 6.6 million b/d in 2027 to average 108.1 million b/d. The recovery in exports has eased market tightness and pushed crude prices lower. North Sea Dated crude fell 32% from an early-October high of $136/bbl to about $93/bbl at the time of the report, although prices remained $22/bbl above prewar levels. Gulf oil exports, excluding Oman, reached 18.4 million b/d in October, about 26% below prewar levels. Crude exports accounted for most of the recovery, reaching 15 million b/d, equivalent to 82% of prewar volumes. However, IEA cautioned that continued attacks on shipping remain a significant downside risk to the supply outlook. Demand under pressure Global oil demand is forecast to decline by 2.7 million b/d in 2026 to 102.3 million b/d, reflecting disruptions to refined product and liquefied petroleum gas exports from the Gulf, elevated fuel prices, and weaker consumption across major markets. The contraction is expected to moderate in fourth-quarter 2026 to 2.7 million b/d year-on-year, compared with an average decline of 4.4 million b/d in the second and

Read More »

Cisco forecasts $9 billion in AI infrastructure revenue in FY27

Cisco continues to benefit from a “networking supercycle,” reporting record revenue—driven by demand for AI infrastructure, security, and campus refreshes from hyperscalers and enterprise customers—for its fiscal first quarter ended October 24. “In Q1, we delivered record quarterly revenue of $18.5 billion, up 24% year over year, and record non-GAAP earnings per share of $1.40, up 40% year over year. These are our strongest top andbottom-line growth rates in over 15 years,” Cisco CEO Chuck Robbins said on the vendor’s quarterly financial call. “Networking product orders grew 28% in Q1, delivering our ninth consecutive quarter of double-digit growth. In fact, we saw double-digit growth across every product family: service provider routing, compute, enterprise routing, wireless, data center switching and campus switching,” Robbins said. “These broad-based results support our view that we are in the early stages of a multiyear, multibillion-dollar networking supercycle.”

Read More »

How TI’s ADC34DSO75 Catches the Nanosecond Power Glitches Behind AI Data Center Downtime

Today’s advanced AI data center can be viewed as a vast, complex and interdependent digital organism in which a virtually infinite number of components must be tracked all the time, in real time. It’s a monitoring job of staggering proportions. At stake is the operation of highly critical workloads and the maintenance of return on investment for high-cost compute equipment. At risk is sub-optimal performance or, in worst-case scenarios, the nightmare of data center downtime. Sponsored Resources: Why traditional telemetry misses nanosecond power-rail events Telemetry has long been relied upon to monitor data center servers, test and measurement equipment, wireless infrastructure and other systems for real-time information about voltage, current, power, temperature and overall system health. But most systems operate at millisecond-level intervals or slower, which is six orders of magnitude longer than the transient events that now occur at the processor power rails and the tools meant to observe them. The requirements and high stakes of today’s AI data centers and workloads have called for a new generation of advanced, nanosecond-level telemetry gear. Texas Instruments has established a leadership position in this sector. The company has developed the first analog-to-digital converter (ADC) to enable 24/7, low-power, event-based remote monitoring at nanosecond resolution. Let’s unpack this statement and examine why TI’s new monitoring technology is so important for the data center industry. What is the TI ADC34DSO75?    We’re talking specifically about TI’s ADC34DSO75, the industry’s highest-performance, 3 gigasamples per second (GSPS) ADC, delivering thousands of times faster performance than current offerings. Launched at the Open Compute Project Global Summit conference in October, the ADC34DSO75 addresses the shortcomings of existing monitoring solutions that can’t detect the nanosecond-level power-rail glitches that cause costly data center downtime. The ADC34DSO75 combines ultra-high-speed sampling with advanced on-chip digital signal processing in a small form factor,

Read More »

SC26 Preview: AI-HPC Convergence Takes Center Stage in Chicago

As the high-performance computing community prepares to gather in Chicago for SC26, November 15–20, the latest episode of the Data Center Frontier Show offers a timely preview of the technologies, market developments, and infrastructure challenges expected to shape this year’s conference. Hosted by DCF Contributing Editor Doug Black, the conversation brings together Lois McKinnis, Argonne Distinguished Fellow and senior computational scientist at Argonne National Laboratory; Addison Snell, founder and CEO of Intersect 360 Research; and Earl Joseph, CEO of Hyperion Research. The episode also inaugurates Data Center Frontier’s new Frontier Computing channel, expanding DCF’s coverage of the technologies and infrastructure driving the convergence of high-performance computing, AI, QC and next-generation scientific discovery. The central theme is unmistakable. AI is no longer simply an adjunct to traditional supercomputing. It is changing how scientific computing itself is performed. “We’re really moving beyond focusing just on bigger machines, faster machines,” McKinnis observes, pointing to the growing integration of AI into scientific software development, simulations, and research workflows. Joseph underscores the acceleration, citing new Hyperion research finding that 70% of respondents are already using AI for code generation. The panel also examines the U.S. Department of Energy’s Genesis Mission, a sweeping effort to link supercomputers, large-scale AI infrastructure, and cloud resources in support of scientific discovery. Joseph calls Genesis “the first time I’ve ever seen something that’s truly a broad national resource,” while Snell emphasizes that investments in AI infrastructure must be matched by investments in science itself. For data center professionals, the discussion turns to increasingly consequential questions about the economics and sustainability of the AI buildout. Snell warns that the industry’s focus on rapid construction has outpaced serious discussion of infrastructure lifecycles and upgrades. Joseph highlights the mounting difficulty of financing supercomputers costing $100 million or more when new GPU generations arrive

Read More »

Nvidia’s leadership crisis puts enterprise AI’s dependence on one company under scrutiny

“More broadly, it throws into doubt the company’s leadership and security practices, and ignites questions around board-level governance and oversight,” he said. The ‘default choice’ in the market Huang founded Nvidia in 1993, initially targeting the gaming market. But the company pivoted in recent years to meet the intensive compute demands of AI. Its advanced GPUs not only excel at rendering graphics, but can handle an enormous number of simultaneous computations, making them a natural fit for neural networks and LLMs. The company began focusing more on developing chips and architecture for AI tools and data centers, and has continued to ink new deals and establish partnerships with tech companies serving nearly every level of the stack, including Anthropic, Meta, Dell, HPE, Microsoft, AWS, Google Cloud, Accenture, Marvell Technology, Hugging Face and many others.

Read More »

Jensen Huang Resigns as NVIDIA CEO, Sending Shockwaves Through AI Data Center Industry

NVIDIA co-founder Jensen Huang resigned Thursday morning (November 12) as president, CEO and board member of the world’s dominant AI chipmaker, a stunning leadership change that introduces new uncertainty into the global artificial intelligence infrastructure boom. In an official announcement, NVIDIA confirmed that Chief Financial Officer Colette Kress will serve as interim CEO while the board conducts a search for Huang’s permanent successor. The company also appointed longtime director Harvey C. Jones as its first board chairman. The departure ends Huang’s 33-year leadership of the company he co-founded in 1993 and comes amid a rapidly escalating controversy involving his reported personal relationships, potential Chinese intelligence activity and questions about corporate governance. According to Reuters, NVIDIA shares fell more than 10% in premarket trading Thursday as investors weighed the implications for the approximately $4 trillion company and the wider AI technology sector. The company’s announcement did not specify a reason for Huang’s resignation. National Security Investigation Precedes Leadership Change The leadership shakeup follows several days of increasing scrutiny over Huang’s reported relationship with a businesswoman whom U.S. authorities suspect of connections to Chinese intelligence, alongside separate reporting concerning a relationship with a senior NVIDIA executive. On November 8, NVIDIA’s board announced an independent investigation into whether Huang had been targeted by a foreign intelligence operation. At the time, directors stated that they had no reason to believe company secrets or national security had been compromised. The controversy subsequently attracted congressional attention, including calls for Huang’s resignation and questions about semiconductor export controls and the security of advanced AI technology. The espionage allegations remain contested, and no compromise of NVIDIA technology has been publicly established. For the data center industry, however, the immediate question extends beyond the circumstances of Huang’s departure. It concerns the potential disruption of an infrastructure ecosystem increasingly organized

Read More »

Google’s Utah Deal Puts Geothermal Power on the Data Center Map

In Taiwan, the Work Begins With Access to Land Google’s first geothermal procurement agreements in Asia call for an initial 10 MW of new generation on Taiwan’s grid to support local data centers and offices. When Google and developer Baseload Capital announced the agreements in April 2025, a Google energy executive told Taiwan Public Television Service that the companies expected operations to begin in 2029. The original timetable allowed roughly four years between signing a customer and delivering electricity. Baseload’s development work in Hualien County illustrates one reason such projects take time. In November 2025, the company reported that members of the Hongye Tribe had voted to approve a public-land lease for geothermal exploration. Baseload opened a local office, reached an agreement with the community, and secured an exploration permit for a two-year program of drilling in stages. The company has described Hongye separately from Google’s contracted supply. What the Hualien project documents is an early milestone rarely visible in a power purchase announcement: the developer secured community consent before drilling could establish what the field might produce. Kenya Has the Generating Field. The Campus Remains Unresolved. In Kenya’s Rift Valley, the appeal of Olkaria was evident when Microsoft and G42 announced their digital investment initiative in 2024. Kenya already had a fleet of geothermal generating stations at Olkaria. G42 and local partners proposed building a campus there, powered by geothermal electricity and hosting Microsoft Azure services for a new East Africa cloud region. Two difficulties emerged. In May 2026, Semafor reported that President William Ruto had cited insufficient available power as an obstacle to the project. Separately, Reuters, citing Bloomberg, reported disagreements over payment guarantees. Microsoft and G42 had sought a commitment from the Kenyan government to buy a certain amount of computing capacity annually. Kenya’s principal secretary for

Read More »

Microsoft will invest $80B in AI data centers in fiscal 2025

And Microsoft isn’t the only one that is ramping up its investments into AI-enabled data centers. Rival cloud service providers are all investing in either upgrading or opening new data centers to capture a larger chunk of business from developers and users of large language models (LLMs).  In a report published in October 2024, Bloomberg Intelligence estimated that demand for generative AI would push Microsoft, AWS, Google, Oracle, Meta, and Apple would between them devote $200 billion to capex in 2025, up from $110 billion in 2023. Microsoft is one of the biggest spenders, followed closely by Google and AWS, Bloomberg Intelligence said. Its estimate of Microsoft’s capital spending on AI, at $62.4 billion for calendar 2025, is lower than Smith’s claim that the company will invest $80 billion in the fiscal year to June 30, 2025. Both figures, though, are way higher than Microsoft’s 2020 capital expenditure of “just” $17.6 billion. The majority of the increased spending is tied to cloud services and the expansion of AI infrastructure needed to provide compute capacity for OpenAI workloads. Separately, last October Amazon CEO Andy Jassy said his company planned total capex spend of $75 billion in 2024 and even more in 2025, with much of it going to AWS, its cloud computing division.

Read More »

John Deere unveils more autonomous farm machines to address skill labor shortage

Join our daily and weekly newsletters for the latest updates and exclusive content on industry-leading AI coverage. Learn More Self-driving tractors might be the path to self-driving cars. John Deere has revealed a new line of autonomous machines and tech across agriculture, construction and commercial landscaping. The Moline, Illinois-based John Deere has been in business for 187 years, yet it’s been a regular as a non-tech company showing off technology at the big tech trade show in Las Vegas and is back at CES 2025 with more autonomous tractors and other vehicles. This is not something we usually cover, but John Deere has a lot of data that is interesting in the big picture of tech. The message from the company is that there aren’t enough skilled farm laborers to do the work that its customers need. It’s been a challenge for most of the last two decades, said Jahmy Hindman, CTO at John Deere, in a briefing. Much of the tech will come this fall and after that. He noted that the average farmer in the U.S. is over 58 and works 12 to 18 hours a day to grow food for us. And he said the American Farm Bureau Federation estimates there are roughly 2.4 million farm jobs that need to be filled annually; and the agricultural work force continues to shrink. (This is my hint to the anti-immigration crowd). John Deere’s autonomous 9RX Tractor. Farmers can oversee it using an app. While each of these industries experiences their own set of challenges, a commonality across all is skilled labor availability. In construction, about 80% percent of contractors struggle to find skilled labor. And in commercial landscaping, 86% of landscaping business owners can’t find labor to fill open positions, he said. “They have to figure out how to do

Read More »

2025 playbook for enterprise AI success, from agents to evals

Join our daily and weekly newsletters for the latest updates and exclusive content on industry-leading AI coverage. Learn More 2025 is poised to be a pivotal year for enterprise AI. The past year has seen rapid innovation, and this year will see the same. This has made it more critical than ever to revisit your AI strategy to stay competitive and create value for your customers. From scaling AI agents to optimizing costs, here are the five critical areas enterprises should prioritize for their AI strategy this year. 1. Agents: the next generation of automation AI agents are no longer theoretical. In 2025, they’re indispensable tools for enterprises looking to streamline operations and enhance customer interactions. Unlike traditional software, agents powered by large language models (LLMs) can make nuanced decisions, navigate complex multi-step tasks, and integrate seamlessly with tools and APIs. At the start of 2024, agents were not ready for prime time, making frustrating mistakes like hallucinating URLs. They started getting better as frontier large language models themselves improved. “Let me put it this way,” said Sam Witteveen, cofounder of Red Dragon, a company that develops agents for companies, and that recently reviewed the 48 agents it built last year. “Interestingly, the ones that we built at the start of the year, a lot of those worked way better at the end of the year just because the models got better.” Witteveen shared this in the video podcast we filmed to discuss these five big trends in detail. Models are getting better and hallucinating less, and they’re also being trained to do agentic tasks. Another feature that the model providers are researching is a way to use the LLM as a judge, and as models get cheaper (something we’ll cover below), companies can use three or more models to

Read More »

OpenAI’s red teaming innovations define new essentials for security leaders in the AI era

Join our daily and weekly newsletters for the latest updates and exclusive content on industry-leading AI coverage. Learn More OpenAI has taken a more aggressive approach to red teaming than its AI competitors, demonstrating its security teams’ advanced capabilities in two areas: multi-step reinforcement and external red teaming. OpenAI recently released two papers that set a new competitive standard for improving the quality, reliability and safety of AI models in these two techniques and more. The first paper, “OpenAI’s Approach to External Red Teaming for AI Models and Systems,” reports that specialized teams outside the company have proven effective in uncovering vulnerabilities that might otherwise have made it into a released model because in-house testing techniques may have missed them. In the second paper, “Diverse and Effective Red Teaming with Auto-Generated Rewards and Multi-Step Reinforcement Learning,” OpenAI introduces an automated framework that relies on iterative reinforcement learning to generate a broad spectrum of novel, wide-ranging attacks. Going all-in on red teaming pays practical, competitive dividends It’s encouraging to see competitive intensity in red teaming growing among AI companies. When Anthropic released its AI red team guidelines in June of last year, it joined AI providers including Google, Microsoft, Nvidia, OpenAI, and even the U.S.’s National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST), which all had released red teaming frameworks. Investing heavily in red teaming yields tangible benefits for security leaders in any organization. OpenAI’s paper on external red teaming provides a detailed analysis of how the company strives to create specialized external teams that include cybersecurity and subject matter experts. The goal is to see if knowledgeable external teams can defeat models’ security perimeters and find gaps in their security, biases and controls that prompt-based testing couldn’t find. What makes OpenAI’s recent papers noteworthy is how well they define using human-in-the-middle

Read More »